The Complete Shopify Plus Migration Checklist: What Your Agency Won't Tell You
A step-by-step checklist for migrating to Shopify Plus — covering SEO preservation, data migration, payment cutover, and the gotchas most agencies discover too late.
Migrating to Shopify Plus is one of the highest-stakes projects an ecommerce brand undertakes. Get it right and you unlock better performance, lower ops overhead, and a platform that scales with you. Get it wrong and you lose organic traffic, break customer accounts, and spend months recovering.
We've completed over 30 platform migrations. Here's the checklist we use — and the mistakes we've seen other agencies make.
Phase 1: Pre-migration audit (weeks 1-2)
Before writing a single line of code, you need a complete picture of what you're migrating from. Skip this phase and you'll discover surprises mid-migration when the cost of change is highest.
URL and SEO inventory
- Crawl every URL on your current site. Tools like Screaming Frog or Sitebulb will give you the full picture. You need: every product URL, collection URL, CMS page, blog post, and any legacy URLs that still receive traffic.
- Map every redirect chain. If your current site has redirects (and it does), you need to know the full chain. A redirect from /old-product to /new-product that then redirects to /final-product is a three-hop chain that Google penalises.
- Export Google Search Console data. Which URLs get impressions? Which drive clicks? This tells you what to protect during migration.
- Document canonical tags. If your current platform uses canonical URLs, those need to map correctly to Shopify's URL structure.
Customer and order data
- Export customer records with all metafields. Shopify's customer import API has limits — 50 fields per record, specific date formats, and address validation rules that reject some international formats.
- Map customer groups to Shopify tags or B2B company accounts. If you use customer-specific pricing, this needs planning before migration.
- Decide on order history. Migrating historical orders is optional but affects customer experience. We usually migrate the last 2 years.
Integration inventory
Document every integration your current store has:
- ERP (NetSuite, SAP, Dynamics 365)
- PIM (Akeneo, Salsify)
- Email/SMS (Klaviyo, Braze, Attentive)
- Reviews (Yotpo, Judge.me, Stamped)
- Search (Algolia, Searchspring)
- Shipping (ShipStation, ShipBob)
- Payment gateways
Each integration needs a migration plan. Some have Shopify-native equivalents; others need custom middleware.
Phase 2: Build and configure (weeks 3-8)
Theme development
Shopify Plus gives you two paths: a Liquid theme (Online Store 2.0) or a Hydrogen headless storefront. For most brands, Liquid is the right choice — it's faster to build, easier to maintain, and Shopify's CDN handles performance automatically.
Choose Hydrogen when you need:
- Sub-200ms page loads for a performance-critical brand
- Full creative control over every pixel
- A React-based frontend your existing team can maintain
- Complex personalisation that Liquid can't handle
Checkout customisation
Shopify Plus unlocks checkout.liquid (or the newer Checkout Extensibility APIs). Plan your checkout customisation early — it's the highest-converting page on your site and the hardest to change later.
Common customisations we build:
- Custom fields (gift messages, delivery instructions)
- Loyalty point redemption at checkout
- Address validation with real-time shipping quotes
- B2B-specific fields (PO numbers, company name)
Phase 3: Data migration and testing (weeks 7-10)
The migration run
We always do at least two full migration runs before the final cutover:
- **Test run 1:** Full data import into a development store. Verify products, customers, orders, and content. Fix mapping issues.
- **Test run 2:** Full data import into the production store (with password protection). Verify again with fresh eyes. Test every integration end-to-end.
- **Final cutover:** The real migration, done during a low-traffic window (usually 2-6am in your primary timezone).
SEO redirect mapping
This is where most agencies fail. You need a 1:1 redirect map from every old URL to its new Shopify equivalent. Shopify's URL structure is fixed:
- Products: /products/product-handle
- Collections: /collections/collection-handle
- Pages: /pages/page-handle
- Blog posts: /blogs/blog-name/post-handle
If your current URLs don't match this pattern, you need 301 redirects. Shopify handles these natively, but you're limited to 100,000 redirects via CSV import — if you have more, you'll need a redirect app or middleware.
Payment gateway cutover
The riskiest moment in any migration is switching payment processing. Our approach:
- Set up Shopify Payments (or your preferred gateway) a week early
- Run test transactions in sandbox mode
- During cutover, disable the old gateway and enable the new one simultaneously
- Monitor the first 50 real transactions closely
- Keep the old gateway credentials accessible for 90 days (chargebacks and disputes on old orders still need processing)
Phase 4: Launch and monitor (weeks 10-12)
Launch day checklist
- Remove password protection
- Verify DNS propagation (allow 24-48 hours)
- Submit updated sitemap to Google Search Console
- Monitor 404 errors in real-time for the first 48 hours
- Verify all integrations are processing live data
- Test checkout with a real transaction
- Confirm email flows (order confirmation, shipping, abandoned cart)
Post-launch monitoring
The first 30 days after migration are critical for SEO:
- Monitor organic traffic daily. A 10-20% dip in the first week is normal as Google re-crawls. If it doesn't recover by week 3, investigate.
- Check for 404 errors. Google Search Console will show these within 2-3 days. Fix immediately.
- Watch page speed. Shopify's CDN is fast, but third-party apps can bloat load times. Audit app impact within the first week.
- Verify structured data. Run your key pages through Google's Rich Results Test. Schema errors won't crash your site but will cost you rich snippets.
Common migration mistakes
- **Not migrating review data.** Your Yotpo or Judge.me reviews have SEO value (they're unique content on product pages). Migrate them.
- **Ignoring the robots.txt during staging.** If your staging store is publicly accessible with a noindex tag, Google may start de-indexing your content. Use password protection instead.
- **Rushing the redirect map.** We've inherited migrations where the agency mapped 500 redirects out of 5,000 needed. The result was thousands of 404 errors and months of recovery.
- **Forgetting about backlinks.** Check your backlink profile. If external sites link to specific URLs on your old domain, those URLs need redirects too.
- **Not planning for the content freeze.** During migration, your marketing team can't update the site. Plan content updates around the migration window.
Planning a migration to Shopify Plus? [Book a free discovery call](https://calendly.com/codifier-info/30min) and we'll walk through your specific situation. Or start with a [free Magento health check](/magento-health-check) if you're migrating from Magento.